Doctors Without Borders closes Afghan hospital, says U.S. may have committed war crime


The medical charity Doctors Without Borders closed its hospital in the Afghan province of Kunduz on Sunday, and charged that a suspected U.S. airstrike that killed 22 people there appeared to have been a war crime.

The closure was a blow to the embattled northern province where more than 400 people have been injured in the last week in fighting between Afghan security forces and the Taliban. The group took control of the provincial capital briefly last week.

The Pentagon said there are three investigations into the airstrike, one by the Defense Department, one involving both the United States and Afghanistan, and one by NATO. Pentagon officials have thus far said only that a U.S. airstrike Saturday morning may have caused collateral damage.


Doctors Without Borders said it would be satisfied only with an investigation by an independent, outside authority.

The aid agency called the bombing, which went on for more than an hour, horrifying and said it had informed U.S. and Afghan officials of the hospital’s GPS coordinates before the strike occurred.

Doctors Without Borders, also known as Medecins sans Frontieres (MSF) in French, said Sunday that the death toll had risen to 22 — 12 staff members and 10 patients, three of them children. The toll was an increase of three over the figure announced previously. In addition, dozens of people were injured.

“Under the clear presumption that a war crime has been committed, MSF demands that a full and transparent investigation into the event be conducted by an independent international body,” the organization said in a statement on its website. “Relying only on an internal investigation by a party to the conflict would be wholly insufficient.”

Senior Pentagon officials said the three investigations that have been launched are centered on whether the U.S. military knew the hospital was nearby when an AC-130 gunship opened fire and whether the clinic was being used by the Taliban to launch attacks.

Thus far, no U.S. or Afghan personnel have been able to gain access to the hospital because the area remains contested, Defense Secretary Ashton Carter said Sunday. He called the situation “confused and complicated.”


The investigation “will be, and needs to be, full and transparent,” Carter told reporters aboard the Pentagon’s E-4B “Doomsday” plane en route to Madrid. “There will be accountability, as always in these incidents, if that is required.”

U.S. Defense officials said small teams of U.S. and Afghan special forces were pinned down by Taliban gunfire Saturday morning near the hospital and called in an AC-130 to pound the area with fire.

The AC-130 Spectre is a heavily armed ground-attack aircraft outfitted with turrets and mounted Gatling-gun style auto cannons that fire rounds powerful enough to rip apart tanks.

Defense officials said that because it was an intense fire exchange with the Taliban, it remains unclear whether the AC-130 was responsible for the hospital’s damage or if it came from elsewhere.

NEWSLETTER: Get the day’s top headlines from Times Editor Davan Maharaj >>

But victims inside the hospital said the strikes continued even after the agency contacted military officials and informed them of the hospital’s position.


Gen. John Campbell, the top commander of U.S. and NATO forces in Afghanistan, has been in constant communication with Carter and Afghan President Ashraf Ghani about the incident. Carter said he said he has not instructed Campbell to halt airstrikes in Afghanistan.

“Gen. Campbell will take whatever actions he thinks are appropriate,” he said. “Right now, he is focused on the investigation and supporting the Afghan security forces.”

Campbell is set to appear in front of Congress to discuss the campaign in Afghanistan and is all but certain to discuss what happened at Kunduz.

Local and international bodies, including the International Committee of the Red Cross, the United Nations and the Ministry of Public Health, have condemned the hospital attack. Afghan forces say that Taliban fighters holed up in the facility were firing at government and U.S. forces, but Doctors Without Borders has disputed these claims.

“MSF is disgusted by the recent statements coming from some Afghanistan government authorities justifying the attack on its hospital in Kunduz,” the organization’s general director, Christopher Stokes, said in a statement issued late Sunday. “These statements imply that Afghan and U.S. forces working together decided to raze to the ground a fully functioning hospital – with more than 180 staff and patients inside – because they claim that members of the Taliban were present. This amounts to an admission of a war crime.”

He added that the claim “utterly contradicts the initial attempts of the U.S. government to minimize the attack as ‘collateral damage.’”


One hospital worker, who said he lost colleagues in the attack, said the Afghan government’s claims are not possible.

“The doors were closed. It was late, no one could get in or out. The only people inside at the time were us — the staff — and the patients.”

For Kunduz residents, basic staples are still hard to come by and many people are afraid to leave their homes. The closure of the hospital is another setback in a week when fighting has left the people waiting for a return to normality.

Wahidullah Mayar, spokesman for the Ministry of Public Health, said the hospital helped reduce the strain on government hospitals, which saw dozens of patients over the last week.

“We have been able to deliver much-needed medical aid to Kunduz but the MSF hospital was an important medical site and its damage will have a major impact on the delivery of additional health services to the people of Kunduz,” Mayar said.

Since the trauma center opened in 2011, it has earned a reputation among the people of Kunduz and northern Afghanistan as the best facility in the region.


Mohammad Yar, 28, knew the hospital was the best choice when he was asked to transport two young men injured in the fighting.

“It’s the name everyone in the north knows, so I thought they would be in good hands there,” he said.

See the most-read stories this hour >>

Like much of the rest of Kunduz, Yar has spent the majority of the last week without power so he was unaware of the airstrike on the hospital.

“I only recently heard about it and I can’t believe it,” he said. “They should have come out happy and healthy, that’s why I sent them there.”

Yar has not received any word from the two men since Friday.

The trauma center has treated more than 394 wounded since fighting broke out last week, and its closure comes at one of the worst possible times for the province.


Safihullah, a member of the provincial council who goes by one name, said people in the province are still relegated to their homes despite government assurances that it had retaken the province Thursday.

“So far, 80 to 90% of the city is cleared of Taliban presence. In the next few days, once it’s fully cleared, that’s when we will know the full human toll and when we will need more hospitals” such as the one run by Doctors Without Borders, he said.

Special correspondent Latifi reported from Kabul and Times staff writer Hennigan from Madrid.


Who gets diplomatic immunity and at which level? That depends

Migrant crisis playing into the hands of Germany’s extremists


Column: What does Russia want in Syria?