Books Jacket Copy

When Maya Angelou was reviewed by Wanda Coleman

Revisiting Wanda Coleman's 2002 review of Maya Angelou: one truth-teller writing about another truth-teller
'What I have always wanted is to be of use,' Angelou once noted. '... Anybody who is not of use is useless'
Maya Angelou led a wave of female African American writers, including Toni Morrison and Wanda Coleman

When I think of Maya Angelou, who died Tuesday at age 86 at her home in Winston-Salem, N.C., I recall Wanda Coleman’s review of her memoir “A Song Flung Up to Heaven,” which appeared in the Los Angeles Times Book Review in April 2002.

By that point Angelou had been a major cultural figure for nearly half a century, a dancer and actress (she appeared, with James Earl Jones, Cicely Tyson and Godfrey Cambridge, in a celebrated 1961 production of Jean Genet’s “The Blacks”) whose 1969 memoir “I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings” — the writing of which was encouraged by her friend James Baldwin — offered a searingly personal evocation of the degradations of racism and violence.

“I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings” put Angelou at the forefront of a wave of female African American writers, including Toni Morrison, Toni Cade Bambera and Audre Lorde. The power of the memoir, Hilton Als observed in the New Yorker, lies in Angelou’s willingness to break down an essential barrier, writing “about blackness from the inside, without apology or defense.”

Coleman, of course, was very much her literary descendant, a poet and essayist who also wrote scathingly about race and class. And yet, she lamented in her review, Angelou had regressed in this, her sixth memoir, to “empty phrases and sweeping generalities.”

To read Coleman’s review now is to marvel, in some ways, at its fairness; she goes out of her way to praise “Caged Bird,” as well as Angelou’s 1986 book “All God’s Children Need Traveling Shoes” and to note her role in Bill Clinton’s 1993 inaugural.

In the moment, though, it sparked a controversy that culminated in Coleman being disinvited from an event at L.A.’s leading African American bookseller, Eso Won Books — although Angelou, to her credit, did not take part in the back-and-forth.

As to why this matters, it tells us something about how we band together behind the writers and artists we consider icons, those who say something important about the way we live. For many readers — Coleman among them — Angelou was precisely such a figure, which is why this review caused such a stir.

I’ve long believed that the most vivid negative reviews are written out of love, or more accurately love disappointed, that the response is a reflection of how important the writing ought to be. This, I’d suggest, is what motivated Coleman:  the desire to take Angelou seriously, not as legend but rather as an essential voice in the community.

“What I have always wanted is to be of use,” Angelou once noted. “I will not be abused. I will not be misused — not willingly. But I will be of use. Anybody who is not of use is useless.”

The same might be said of Coleman. In that sense, she was paying Angelou the respect she deserved as one of the progenitors of contemporary African American literature: one truth-teller writing about another truth-teller, holding both of them to the highest standards of their art.

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Steve Martin joins 'Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk' adaptation
    Steve Martin joins 'Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk' adaptation

    The film adaptation of Ben Fountain's novel "Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk" has its first big star. Steve Martin will join debut actor Joe Alwyn, and possibly Garrett Hedlund, in Ang Lee's movie version of the Iraq war satire, Deadline reports.

  • T.C. Boyle, LeVar Burton lead L.A. Times Book Prizes
    T.C. Boyle, LeVar Burton lead L.A. Times Book Prizes

    The 35th annual L.A. Times Book Prizes are announced today. There are five finalists in 10 categories, and two prize winners were revealed: The Robert Kirsch Award for Lifetime Achievement will be presented to author T.C. Boyle, and LeVar Burton will be honored with the Innovators Award for...

  • Maya Angelou postage stamp revealed
    Maya Angelou postage stamp revealed

    The U.S. Postal Service has revealed its Forever postage stamp featuring Maya Angelou, the poet and author widely known for her autobiography "I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings."

  • Steven Spielberg, Jennifer Lawrence to film Lynsey Addario's story
    Steven Spielberg, Jennifer Lawrence to film Lynsey Addario's story

    Jennifer Lawrence, the Oscar-winning actress who stars as Katniss Everdeen in the "Hunger Games" films, will portray real-life photojournalist Lynsey Addario in a film based on her memoir "It's What I Do." Steven Spielberg will direct.

  • Kansas and the right to free expression
    Kansas and the right to free expression

    Last week, by a vote of 26-14, the Kansas Senate passed SB 56, a bill that amends the state’s existing public morals law by striking an exemption that protects teachers from prosecution for exposing students to "harmful material."

  • Ursula K. Le Guin slams new Kazuo Ishiguro novel
    Ursula K. Le Guin slams new Kazuo Ishiguro novel

    Kazuo Ishiguro's new novel "The Buried Giant" has so far garnered mixed reactions from critics, with some praising the author for his foray into fantasy, and others finding the result "misbegotten." In a blog post published yesterday, fantasy legend Ursula K. Le Guin left little doubt...

Comments
Loading