Opinion Editorial

L.A., where tax breaks come easy -- for some

Nearly a decade ago, when Los Angeles gave a $270-million tax break to the developer of a 1,000-room luxury hotel at L.A. Live, city leaders described the deal as essential to spur downtown redevelopment and help the struggling Convention Center.

Today, however, downtown is booming and its hotels are doing brisk business, yet developers continue to line up for taxpayer handouts. Four more hotel projects have been approved for tax breaks worth half a billion dollars over the next two decades — money that otherwise would pay for police and fire services, street paving and tree trimming. Three more developers have asked for subsidies, and the City Council will vote Wednesday to study one of the requests. And it's not just hotels: In March, city leaders let mall developer Westfield keep $59 million in city taxes for building a new shopping center in suburban Woodland Hills.

Convention Center Executive Director Robert "Bud" Ovrom recently took on the touchy subject of tax incentives. He agrees that L.A. needs more hotel rooms, but he questioned whether the projects seeking subsidies would include enough new rooms to help the Convention Center attract bigger, more profitable events. Ovrom called for a fresh look at how Los Angeles is using incentives downtown, but he raised points that should be considered citywide.

The City Council and the mayor run the risk of making tax breaks for big developers the norm. There is no comprehensive policy guiding decisions on when the city should consider subsidies to encourage economic development, which projects merit help or what taxpayers should get in return. As it is now, developers go to City Hall, pay for an independent economic analysis, and, if they have a "funding gap," the city will generally allow them to keep about 50% of the new sales, hotel, utility and property taxes the project will generate for 25 years.

Proponents of the tax breaks say the city benefits from the construction, and that 50% of something is better than 100% of nothing. But that assumes developers won't build in L.A. without an incentive. Perhaps that's true of some projects in some communities; undoubtedly subsidies can play an important role in spurring economic development.

But would Westfield really have walked away from the fancy shopping center it wanted to build in Woodland Hills if it hadn't gotten a tax break? It had already put nearly a decade into the process and gone through an environmental review, and it owns another shopping center directly across the street that houses Neiman Marcus and Cartier.

The city needs a more careful and studied approach to the process so that developers don't immediately head to City Hall seeking subsidies they don't need — and that don't bring benefits for taxpayers.

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Where's our public art? Wrapped up in red tape.
    Where's our public art? Wrapped up in red tape.

    It was a smart idea to set up the Arts Development Fee Trust Fund. But it's dumb not to spend it.

  • A practical Eric Garcetti takes a modest swipe at L.A.'s business tax
    A practical Eric Garcetti takes a modest swipe at L.A.'s business tax

    Mayor Eric Garcetti dropped no bombshells when he released his first budget Monday. The $8.1-billion spending plan was in line with the theme of his administration so far: focus on basic city functions, improve customer service, control costs and win back public trust. All in all, it’s...

  • South L.A. needs trees
    South L.A. needs trees

    Light-rail construction will doom more than 100 trees along Crenshaw Boulevard. City and county officials must follow through on ambitious plans for creating an inviting streetscape.

  • Would it hurt City Hall to look into rise in worker injury claims?
    Would it hurt City Hall to look into rise in worker injury claims?

    The cost of paying salaries to Los Angeles civilian workers who are temporarily disabled because they have been hurt on the job has gone up 50% over five years, reaching $18 million last year. Employees are claiming more injuries and taking longer injury leaves. City officials don't know why...

  • Should non-citizens in the U.S. vote?
    Should non-citizens in the U.S. vote?

    As of Jan. 1, 2012, an estimated 13.3 million lawful permanent residents lived in the United States, and 8.8 million of them were eligible to apply for U.S. citizenship but had not done so. In California, 2.48 million out of 3.4 million green-card holders were eligible to apply but chose not...

  • Obama's fourth-quarter foreign policy surprises
    Obama's fourth-quarter foreign policy surprises

    Six months ago, President Obama's foreign policy looked stymied. Negotiations with Israel and the Palestinians were at a dead end. Russia was gaining ground in eastern Ukraine. U.S. efforts to end the war in Syria were ineffective. A new extremist army, Islamic State, was marching into Iraq.