Advertisement

A Place to Call Home : Immigrants flooding into Southern California often accept living conditions far worse than what they left in their native lands.

Share
TIMES STAFF WRITER

Most of Nestor Urcuyo’s personal belongings fit neatly into a large plastic trash bag. That fact has served him well during the past five years, when he’s moved more often than a raveling salesman on commission.

His current home is a cramped two-bedroom trailer that he shares with two other men in a trailer park nearly hidden from view along Balboa Boulevard in Van Nuys. While the dilapidated trailer has obviously seen better days, it still boasts some features that Urcuyo’s neighbors covet. Indoor plumbing, for example.

But for all its shortcomings, the trailer marks a major step up from what Urcuyo has learned to accept since fleeing his native Nicaragua in 1987 to avoid the military draft. He has shared a one-bedroom apartment with as many as 10 people, slept on more floors than a defenseless prizefighter and, for one ignominious winter, paid more than $100 a month in rent to sleep in an unheated garage amid mounds of discarded aluminum cans and other trash.

Advertisement

Once pampered and protected in his homeland, Urcuyo now works long hours at a tedious job in a Chatsworth garment factory, taking home just $90 a week. That meager salary has left him dangerously close to homelessness, but his experience is not unique. Many of the recent immigrants who have flooded Southern California--whether to escape political persecution at home or simply in search of work--have been forced to accept living conditions far worse than those they left in their Third World homelands.

In San Diego’s North County, for example, dayworkers have banded together to build “homes” from cardboard boxes in the hills above exclusive planned communities. In the San Fernando Valley, new arrivals are more likely to pool their meager resources to rent cheap apartments, cramming more than a half-dozen people into a one-bedroom unit.

“To us, seven or eight people in a room is unacceptable. But these people do whatever it takes,” said Arnold Ross-Stalk, the former executive director of the L.A. Family Housing Corp. “It’s tough, but it’s always been tough.

“My grandparents came here from Poland and did real similar things. They doubled, tripled and quadrupled up in apartments. They pooled their resources. That’s the same thing these people do. They support each other,” said Ross-Stalk, who directs a Woodland Hills architectural firm specializing in low-cost housing.

Several studies have shown that overcrowded conditions--defined as more than one person per room per unit--have been rising rapidly since the early ‘80s. The problem has long been acute in rural areas such as Oxnard, Indio and the Central California valleys, which attract large numbers of migrant farm workers. But as immigration has swelled, the number of undocumented dayworkers congregating on urban street corners has grown as well, adding to the strain on available housing.

In San Fernando, for example, 52.2% of the city’s rental units are overcrowded, the ninth-highest rate in the region and more than 10 times the national average of 4.9%.

Advertisement

Landlords are often powerless to stop overcrowding because the state’s Uniform Housing Code, which is based on the number of square footage per unit per person, is extremely liberal. Several cities, responding to complaints from local activists, have challenged the law and attempted to write regulations of their own, only to be rebuffed. The city of Santa Ana, which says interpretations of the current code could allow as many as 10 residents in a one-bedroom apartment, last year proposed an ordinance that would have halved that number. The state responded by saying it does not have the authority to allow cities to adopt stricter local standards than the state’s code.

But Ross-Stalk and others say overcrowding is the result of a lack of affordable housing, not the law. The median monthly rent for a one-bedroom apartment in the Valley is $582 and most building managers also require sizable deposits on top of that.

“We don’t have enough housing, and the housing that’s out there just costs too much,” says Marc Brown, a staff attorney for the Sacramento-based Rural Legal Assistance Foundation. But there are few local alternatives. As Ross-Stalk notes, “the Valley does not have a shelter for single people.”

Overcrowding seems to affect Latin American immigrants most. The sheer complexity of emigrating from Africa, Asia or Europe often requires a great deal of planning and saving, so new arrivals from those parts of the world either come with sufficient resources or can count on friends and family to provide immediate housing and other help. But for many Latinos, immigration can be as simple as walking across the border, so roommates are often chosen on the basis of a shared desperation and a common language rather than any real affinity.

That can lead to stressful relationships, which is one reason Urcuyo has moved seven times in the past three years.

Ana Maria Gomez, who lived in the same house for 26 years in El Salvador, has changed residences at least seven times in the 12 years she has lived in this country. Her first home was the living room of a friend’s apartment in Culver City, but since then she’s spent much of her time as a live-in housekeeper and baby-sitter for a succession of families.

Advertisement

Because many families are willing to provide room and board and pay undocumented housekeepers under the table, such jobs are highly sought by Latina immigrants. A popular commercial on Spanish-language television has even seized on the trend, featuring a character named Lupe who works for Mrs. Taylor, a well-heeled, blond career woman who can’t choose a dentist without her housekeeper’s help. But Lupe may be the first domestic since Hazel who actually enjoys her work. Many woman say they tolerate such jobs because they provide steady work and a safe place to live.

Aura Ugarte, who has lived with and worked for the same family for more than four years, still feels like an intruder. “I feel like what I am: an employee,” she says. “I feel bad. I don’t feel like I have rights to anything that isn’t mine.”

Gomez, 38, can sympathize with Ugarte. She has few fond memories of her first job in the United States.

“It was terrible,” she says. “The family took care of me, but they really didn’t pay me much, just $75 a week. They didn’t let me go to school either and the thing I really wanted to do was to learn English.”

After 18 months, she found a family in the Valley that supported her educational goals, changed jobs and eventually saved enough to afford the $625 a month rent on a modest two-bedroom apartment in Canoga Park.

“It was good and big and I had good friends there,” she remembers. “I wanted to rent the second bedroom to someone else, to help them and to help me.”

Advertisement

After living for years as the outsider in homes of strangers, a place of her own had become Gomez’s American dream. But it was a dream that soon kept her up at night. Although she found a man from her homeland whom she trusted to live with her, his wife spent most of her time drinking and, Gomez said, “she made life bad for everyone.”

As a result, Gomez was forced to abandon the home she had worked so long to afford.

“When you try to rent to somebody, you don’t always know that person well,” she said. “I was really scared. I had a 6-month-old baby but I couldn’t afford anything on my own.”

Eventually, she was the one who moved out.

“It was difficult for me,” she says. “I was really sad I had to move.”

If finding suitable housing for one person can be a challenge, providing for a family can be next to impossible, which is why many immigrants who come to the Valley for short-term or seasonal work travel alone. For starters, it’s difficult to find roommates willing to share rent with a family, and it’s more expensive to feed and clothe children at prices double or triple the going rate in Latin America.

One dayworker from Mexico City, who asked that his name not be used, lived for several months with a group of men in a small apartment. But, like his roommates, he grew despondent without his wife and two children nearby.

“Many Hispanics, because of the loneliness, they drink,” he said. “It’s bad, but sometimes you need a glass to cope.”

Despite infrequent work and his feelings of isolation, he was able to save enough to send for his family, settling them in a North Hills apartment. But lacking a steady income and without others to share expenses, he quickly fell behind on the rent and is now planning to return soon to Mexico City.

Advertisement

“We’re worse off than we were in Mexico,” he says. “I feel bad for my kids. When they want a hamburger or shoes or something, I have to tell them they can’t have it.”

Gomez, however, is staying put, having proven to be a survivor, if nothing else. After all her earlier disappointments, she has finally found a clean, cheap apartment in Reseda, where she lives with her sister. But she may be looking for a new roommate shortly.

“My sister is going back home soon,” she said. “It’s hard to survive here. She doesn’t like it here.

“But me, I’m going to stay.”

Advertisement