Father and son charged with starting Caldor fire near Lake Tahoe plead not guilty

Flames and smoke rise from a wooded mountain ridge
The Caldor fire is seen burning in Eldorado National Forest on Aug. 29.
(Noah Berger / Associated Press)

A father and son charged with starting the Caldor fire, which destroyed many homes and forced tens of thousands of people to flee Lake Tahoe communities this year, pleaded not guilty in court Friday.

The El Dorado County district attorney’s office charged David Scott Smith, 66, and Travis Shane Smith, 32, with reckless arson. The office also charged the son with illegal conversion or manufacture of a machine gun and both men with illegal possession of a firearm silencer.

The defendants pleaded not guilty to all charges, said Emily Idleman, assistant to the chief of investigations in the district attorney’s office.


The men were arrested Wednesday and remain in El Dorado County Jail in lieu of $1-million bail each. A bail reduction hearing is scheduled for Monday.

The criminal complaints do not specify whether the machine gun and silencer tie into the Caldor fire, and the district attorney’s office has not offered an explanation. The fire started Aug. 14 and crossed three Northern California counties, forcing tens of thousands of people to evacuate the resort city of South Lake Tahoe before it was contained in October.

Five people were injured and about 1,000 homes and other buildings were destroyed.

The Caldor fire has also changed the view of fire risk in Lake Tahoe.

Aug. 31, 2021

The complaints said that both men illegally possessed a firearm silencer between Aug. 11 and Sept. 23 and that Travis Smith converted or manufactured a machine gun between Aug. 9 and Aug. 14.

Mark Reichel, the attorney for both men, said previously that the two were near where the fire started and called 911 to report flames.

“Neither one has ever been in trouble with the law in their life. They’re very law-abiding people,” he said.


The Caldor fire scorched more than 346 square miles from east of Sacramento to the Nevada border, threatening ski resorts and other prominent recreational areas.

The district attorney’s office said the case was developed with the U.S. Forest Service, the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection and the California Department of Justice, with help from the Sacramento County district attorney’s crime lab.