To the editor: My heart fell reading Tamar Jacoby's article about newly arrived immigrants who struggle to learn English. Of course immigrants need to be proficient in English to achieve the American dream. But proficiency for adults takes years of everyday study with qualified teachers. ("Beyond survival English," Opinion, Jan. 5)
For more than 100 years, the
In 2012, then-Supt.
Yes, our immigrants need to be given easy access to American English classes if we are to all succeed in our society. LAUSD has a lot to answer for.
Planaria Price, Los Angeles
To the editor: By failing to put the issue into proper historical perspective, Jacoby creates unrealistic expectations about what public schools can do.
In 1905, New York City was inundated with far more non-English speaking immigrants than now live in Los Angeles. As Irving Howe wrote in "World of Our Fathers," the New York system did "rather well in helping immigrant children who wanted help, fairly well in helping those who needed help, and quite badly in helping those who resisted help."
Instead of persisting in the fiction that all newcomers to these shores have the same motivation to become proficient in English, it's important to remember the lessons from the past.
Walt Gardner, Los Angeles
The writer is the author of Education Week's Reality Check blog.