Editorial: Only banning guns from movie sets will prevent the ‘Rust’ tragedy from ever happening again

Two people are around a movie camera.
Cinematographer Halyna Hutchins on the set of the music video for Rachel Mason’s “Give You Everything.”
(Courtesy of Rachel Mason)

More than a year after the shocking fatal shooting of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins on the New Mexico set of the movie “Rust,” prosecutors announced Thursday that they will file criminal charges of involuntary manslaughter against Alec Baldwin, the star of the movie who allegedly discharged the replica of a vintage Colt .45.

They will file the same charges against the film’s armorer, Hannah Gutierrez Reed, whose job it was to check the guns to make sure they were safe to handle. The gunshot also wounded director Joel Souza, who survived, but no charges are being filed in connection with that.

“On my watch, no one is above the law, and everyone deserves justice,” New Mexico’s 1st Judicial Dist. Atty. Mary Carmack-Altwies said.


We certainly agree and want the court system to decide the matter fairly. But whatever the legal outcome of events on that afternoon in 2021 during a rehearsal in which Baldwin pointed a gun in the direction of Hutchins, this was a tragedy that should never happen again.

If studios and labor unions don’t reach an agreement on keeping sets safe, the Legislature must be willing to act.

May 24, 2022

The low-budget, 21-day film shoot was beset by problems — complaints from the crew about working conditions, a walkout by half a dozen camera crew members in protest, and at least two accidental prop gun discharges earlier in the filming, according to a report in The Times. We already know that many things went wrong on that set the day of the shooting. Gutierrez Reed, who was juggling responsibilities as armorer and a props assistant, has said she checked the gun that day but not right before the rehearsal.

According to Santa Fe County Sheriff’s Office documents, the film’s assistant director, Dave Halls, who was also the safety director on the set, handed the gun to Baldwin and said it was “cold,” meaning it contained no live ammunition. That would turn out to be fatally wrong. The gun contained at least one live round — forbidden on sets — mixed in with dummy rounds, which contain no gunpowder. Halls reached a plea deal with prosecutors to accept a misdemeanor charge of negligent use of a deadly weapon.

The “Rust” accidental shooting has prompted many to wonder why real guns are still used on TV and film sets. It’s a good question, and one that writers and directors should consider.

Oct. 26, 2021

The point is that no one has to use any kind of gun on a movie or TV set. Even though accidental shootings like this are thankfully rare, too many things have to go right so that nothing goes horribly wrong. “Under the best circumstances, mistakes can be made, props that purposely look identical to each other can get mixed up, and the necessary handling of these props can cause malfunction,” says Spencer Parsons, associate professor and head of production at Northwestern University in the School of Communication’s Department of Radio/Television/Film.

Attempts to legislate better protections on sets fizzled in the California Legislature last spring. That’s unfortunate, and it returns the responsibility to makers of films and TV shows. Why can’t Hollywood screen wizards create the effects of firearms without having to use even prop guns with dummy rounds? If they can make an actress look like “M3GAN,” an AI doll that’s terrifying moviegoers in droves, why can’t they simulate a firearm discharge — and the recoil that the shooter experiences — without having a real weapon on set?

These are issues that directors and writers should be seriously addressing. Let’s eliminate the possibility that actors or crew members could get shot on a set.