Greg Cosell, a senior producer for NFL Films, spends a lot of his life in the dark breaking down game footage and evaluating college prospects. But the light that he sheds on quarterbacks is coveted information in NFL circles. Here is a sampling of his observations on four of the top quarterback prospects heading into the draft:
Joe Burrow, LSU
- Poised and composed in pocket. Good ball position. Light feet, good balance, firm base, compact delivery.
- A quick processor of pressures and coverage with high-level elimination and isolation traits.
- Efficient pocket movement keeping his eyes up, maintaining downfield focus, always ready to throw.
- Tendency to lift his back foot off the ground a beat early, minimizing ability to drive the ball.
- Not a velocity thrower. Lacking higher-level arm strength.
- Some snaps in which Burrow climbed the pocket needlessly and moved into pressure.
Tua Tagovailoa, Alabama
- Very quick feet on his drop and set with excellent ball positions and an efficient, compact delivery.
- More of a touch, pace thrower than a drive-power thrower. Good feel in the short-to-intermediate pass game.
- Threw an excellent deep ball with good trajectory and consistent accuracy when he had space in the pocket.
- A little bit of a pusher with his delivery, which limits velocity and his ability to drive the ball.
- Still needs refinement as a progression reader. Left too many throws on the field.
- Not a twitchy, explosive athlete on the move. Does not have the short-area burst to run away from NFL defenders.
Justin Herbert, Oregon
- Showed ability to make strong, accurate throws both off designed boot and second-reaction movement.
- Nuanced feel for the details of the screen game with his drop back and footwork.
- Made far-hash/deep-sideline throws with little effort and good ball placement.
- Erratic and inconsistent accuracy an issue throughout Herbert’s tape.
- Definite questions regarding timing and anticipation. A beat late on too many throws. Not a rhythmic ball distributor.
- Some question about field vision when the primary read was taken away.
Jordan Love, Utah State
- Made some tough throws into tight windows versus man and zone coverage.
- Attacked the one-on-one coverage on the outside. An aggressive thrower with a turn-it-loose mentality.
- Showed a good sense of timing out of the shotgun in the quick game. Planted and delivered.
- At times dropped his arm angle, which resulted in ball-placement issues.
- Needs much work on his lower-body mechanics. Did not consistently plant his back foot on deeper drops.
- Struggled at times to locate and process underneath defenders on intermediate throws. A defining issue on some of his interceptions.