College football: Army outlasts Navy in two overtimes in rivalry’s first OT game
Navy fullback Anton Hall Jr. collapsed to the ground and buried his face in his hands. West Point cadets spilled from the stands onto the field and joined Army players who ripped off their helmets and ran around in celebration.
Hall’s push toward the end zone in the second overtime — and first overtime game in Army-Navy history — resulted in a fumble that Army recovered. The Black Knights went from potentially playing for a tie to simply playing for a winning score.
“Somehow, the ball got loose and we hit that thing when we needed to,” Army coach Jeff Monken said.
Quinn Maretzki kicked a game-winning, 39-yard field goal after he had sent the game into overtime with a 37-yard field goal late in the fourth quarter and led Army past the Midshipmen 20-17 on Saturday night in the first overtime game in the 123 matchups of “America’s Game.”
“It’s obviously a big moment, but I try my best to put that aside,” Maretzki said. “Just being able to block everything out, [my teammates] just made that job so easy for me. So I just had to go out there and not even really think.”
After a stellar 2022 campaign, USC quarterback Caleb Williams wins the Heisman Trophy, beating out runner-up Max Duggan, C.J. Stroud and Stetson Bennett.
Hall — who earlier raced 77 yards for a touchdown and 10-7 lead — fumbled the ball as he plunged toward the end zone and stood crestfallen as Maretzki prepared to kick the winner. Hall dropped to the ground as the kick sailed through the uprights, and he was consoled by teammate Amin Hassan. But the fullback’s fumble forced by Austin Hill and recovered by defensive lineman Nate Smith will forever be etched on the highlight reel of game-changing plays in the series.
“The game is not lost with him. That could happen to anyone that was carrying the ball on that one play,” Navy quarterback Xavier Arline said. “They made a good play. That’s football. That’s life. The game was not lost within that one play.”
Navy coach Ken Niumatalolo stood hunched on the sideline and could not stomach to watch the final field goal.
“What do you tell them when you get your heart broken?” Niumatalolo said. “We were in the driver’s seat. We were feeling pretty good. Unfortunately, the game slipped out of our hands.”
The offenses were stagnant throughout the game until the waning moments of regulation when Maretzki kicked the 37-yarder with 1:53 left to tie the score at 10.
A thrilling overtime followed.
The NCAA instituted overtime in 1996, and the series had never had to go a little extra to settle one of college football’s greatest rivalry games.
Army’s Markel Johnson ran 25 yards for a touchdown on the first play of overtime for a 17-10 lead, and Navy matched the Black Knights when Arline tossed a 25-yard touchdown pass to Maquel Haywood that made it 17-all.
It was Navy’s first completion of the game. Arline finished one-for-one passing for 25 yards and rushed for 102 yards.
Navy still leads the series against Army 62-54-7. The Black Knights, though, have won five of the last seven meetings.
Army finished 6-6 this season; Navy was 4-8.
“This team never stopping fighting. They never stopped believing,” Monken said. “Somehow, some way, we found a way to get it done tonight. It was an epic battle. It was one I’ll remember for a long time, probably forever.”
An attempt at ranking all eight USC Heisman Trophy winners. Where do Caleb Williams, Reggie Bush and O.J. Simpson rank?
The teams combined for only 53 yards passing.
One of Cade Ballard’s rare passing attempts for Army was a success when a pass-interference call brought the ball to Navy’s 28-yard line with four minutes left on a drive that set up Maretzki’s tying field goal.
Ballard was two-for-10 passing for 26 yards.
Hall’s run up the middle in the third quarter was the biggest burst of offense of the game for either team — at that point, that run alone had outgained Army’s 69 total yards.
His run was a double gut punch to the Black Knights after quarterback Tyhier Tyler’s 40-yard touchdown run was wiped out on a penalty on the previous possession.
Hall provided one of the few highlights in a game full of wobbly punts, errant throws and a dearth of first downs.
The first spark came in the final seconds of the first half when Army’s Noah Short blocked Riley Riethaman’s punt and Jabril Williams recovered — after almost knocking the ball out of the end zone — for the touchdown and a 7-3 lead.
That bit of excitement in front of a packed house of 69,117 at Lincoln Financial Field just about made up for 29 minutes of two offenses that could not move the ball down field.
The first half ended with 0 yards passing. From both teams. Zero.
That statistic of futility wasn’t necessarily uncommon for either program. Navy won two games this season without completing a pass, and Army threw for 852 yards — this season. That’s about 2½ games of yardage on the same field for Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts.
Former USC Heisman winner Charles White is suffering from Stage 2 dementia and living in an assisted care facility. He still hopes for a USC reunion.
With points at a premium, Navy sent out Bijan Nichols for a long field goal, and his 44-yarder hugged the inside of the right goal post for a 3-0 lead in the second quarter.
Army finished the half 0-for-5 passing, failed to convert on five of six third downs and had 33 total yards in the half.
This game is rarely about quality football anyway and more about the pageantry and revelry of cadets and midshipmen standing, bouncing and cheering for their branch.
The hours before kickoff were highlighted by the Army Corps of Cadets and the Brigade of Midshipmen march onto the field. The Navy “Leap Frogs” parachute team earned a roar from the crowd with each safe landing on the field. Mark Wahlberg even made an appearance and leaped into a crowd of midshipmen and then received an award for his work with the military.
Quarterback Dorian Thompson-Robinson and running back Zach Charbonnet took part in UCLA’s practice that was open to reporters ahead of the Sun Bowl.
Noteworthy
It was the 90th time the game was played in Philadelphia, including 38 straight times from 1945 to 1982.
The series is hitting the road starting with next season’s game in Foxborough, Mass. The 2024 game is at FedEx Field in Landover, Md.; 2025 is at M&T Bank Stadium in Baltimore; and 2026 is at MetLife Stadium, the New Jersey home of the Jets and Giants just outside New York City. The game returns to Philadelphia in 2027.
Get our high school sports newsletter
Prep Rally is devoted to the SoCal high school sports experience, bringing you scores, stories and a behind-the-scenes look at what makes prep sports so popular.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.
