Mubarak’s arrest a watershed moment for Egypt

For almost three decades he wielded unquestioned power, a seemingly invincible figure ruling with a sense of privilege and ruthlessness that epitomized autocrats across the Middle East.

Even when mass protests improbably forced him from power in February, it appeared highly unlikely that Hosni Mubarak, long a key U.S. ally in a volatile region, would ever be held to account for allegations of corruption and abuse of office.

But that all changed Wednesday, when authorities here confirmed the detention of the former Egyptian president and his two sons, a move immediately hailed by many as a surprising but shrewd step by the ruling military council to calm protests in the world’s most populous Arab nation.

“This is a landmark in the history of Egypt and the history of the Arab world,” said a jubilant Alaa Al Aswany, a well-known novelist and pro-democracy activist.


All at once, a long-unimaginable spectacle — a trio of Mubaraks under interrogation for corruption, abuse of power and other alleged crimes, including deadly violence against protesters — seemed like it might become reality. The long-elusive goal of accountability looms as potentially the next accomplishment of what people here simply call the Revolution, the 18 days of street protests that culminated in Mubarak’s resignation Feb. 11.

It is also a sign to the leaders of Yemen, Syria and other nations in turmoil of the risk of ceding power in the face of popular revolts. Yemeni President Ali Abdullah Saleh and Syrian President Bashar Assad have responded with more violent crackdowns than Mubarak did as they seek to prevent protesters from gaining momentum. Saleh has even demanded immunity from prosecution as a condition of his possibly stepping down.

A potential criminal prosecution in Egypt would seem to end whispers of political redemption for Mubarak, 82, and his inner circle, including sons Gamal and Alaa.

Gamal, a Western-educated banker and businessman, long considered a potential successor to his father, is under investigation for alleged financial crimes ranging from Cairo to Geneva to London. So is his brother, Alaa, who relied on his father’s connections to force his way into profitable businesses and to intimidate rivals.


The detentions are seen as a wise political move by the military council that now rules Egypt. In recent weeks, the council has been criticized for not going after Mubarak, a former air force commander. Hours after the arrests were announced, the rancor toward the military began to diminish as opposition groups called off demonstrations planned for Friday.

The prospect of Mubarak and his sons in court underscores how drastically the so-called Arab Spring protests have reshaped the contours of the Middle East, a place where presidents and potentates have routinely evaded legal reckoning after lifetimes of repression and corruption.

In fact, many here suspected that Mubarak agreed to step down only after receiving guarantees that he and his sons would never face prosecution. Now it seems any such deal is off the table. Mubarak’s spiral from the pinnacle of power to status of reviled prisoner and possible defendant has been a tantalizing mix of crime show theatrics and morality play.

“This is the step we have been waiting to see for a long time,” said Abdel Rahman Mansour, a member of the youth coalition whose protests helped topple Mubarak.


In Cairo’s Tahrir Square, the epicenter of the Egyptian uprising, the stunning news of Mubarak’s detention eclipsed the sense of uncertainty that had prevailed during recent protests questioning the military council’s resolve to proceed against him. Mubarak had been living in his private palace in Sharm el Sheik since stepping down.

“Mubarak arrested!” a jubilant Magdy Bakeri Mohamed, who said he had been a political prisoner for 12 years during the ex-president’s regime, shouted over and over as he handed out celebratory sweets to passers-by in the square. “Mubarak arrested!”

Authorities confirmed early Wednesday that the ailing Mubarak was placed under detention in his hospital room, where he was being treated for chest pains he said had started this week during questioning by prosecutors.

Mubarak’s sons were to be interrogated about corruption allegations at a Cairo prison that normally holds thieves and political dissidents.


Even if Mubarak is eventually cleared, the mere fact that he is being subjected to a criminal proceeding is highly significant, said Diaa Rashwan, a political analyst at Al Ahram Center for Political and Strategic Studies.

“We are talking about symbols here, people who were once considered untouchable,” Rashwan said. “Talking about Mubarak and his family was a taboo here in Egypt, so this is of great symbolic importance.”

News of the detentions seemed to reinvigorate the political opposition that brought down Mubarak.

“This step may have come a bit late, but it is a step in the right direction,” said Mohamed Beltagui of the Muslim Brotherhood, the Islamist group that is one of the nation’s largest and best-organized political blocs. “No one is above the law.”


The Mubaraks will now face 15 days of detention, as called for under Egyptian law, while authorities carry out their inquiries. No one has yet been formally charged and there is no guarantee of a trial. Opposition figures were quick to insist that Mubarak be treated like anyone else facing a criminal inquiry. During Mubarak’s rule, some Egyptians were held indefinitely without being charged and were treated brutally.

“It is time to bring Mubarak to justice,” said Mohamed Abdel Qudous, a political activist and columnist. “He should face a fair trial in a civilian court and be able to defend himself.”

The case is extremely sensitive for the cadre of generals who sit on the ruling council.

Mubarak, who enjoyed the military’s support throughout his rule, which began after the 1981 assassination of President Anwar Sadat, himself a former military man, finds himself adrift from the generals. That includes Field Marshall Mohamed Hussein Tantawi, head of the council, who was once referred to as Mubarak’s poodle.


But the arrests also could reignite passions and lead to renewed unrest, from both anti-Mubarak factions and from his supporters, who in recent weeks have attacked protesters.

The arrests may partly reflect the military’s long disdain for Gamal Mubarak, one of the architects of the country’s painful economic reform plan that further enriched the wealthy but did little to improve the lives of the more than 40% of Egyptians who live on $2 a day or less. The military leadership criticized the plan as creating “social instability” among the poor and working classes.

A leaked 2008 U.S. diplomatic cable quotes an unnamed Egyptian analyst as saying he had been told by army officers “that the military does not support Gamal and if Mubarak died in office, the military would seize power rather than allow Gamal to succeed his father.”

Today, Hosni Mubarak’s predicament mars the veneer of honor and respect he so craved.


“I can’t remain silent toward the campaigns of falsehood, slander and defamation and the continuous attempts to ruin my and my family’s reputation and integrity,” Mubarak said in an address to the country Sunday, denying any financial wrongdoing. His critics, Mubarak said, were “questioning my integrity, stances and military and political history, through which I have striven for the sake of Egypt and its sons in war and peace.”

Amro Hassan of The Times’ Cairo bureau contributed to this report.