Ramirez Ordered to Stand Trial on 14 Murder Counts in Night Stalker Case
Night Stalker suspect Richard Ramirez was ordered Tuesday to stand trial on 14 murder charges and 36 other felony counts stemming from a brutal crime rampage that gripped Los Angeles County in a wave of terror last year.
Los Angeles Municipal Judge James F. Nelson issued his ruling without comment before a packed courtroom at the conclusion of an arduous, 29-day preliminary hearing in which 143 prosecution witnesses took the stand.
Ramirez, a 26-year-old drifter from El Paso, occasionally flashed a grin and scratched his face as Nelson went through the charges, one by one, before scheduling a May 21 arraignment date in Los Angeles Superior Court.
Nelson ordered Ramirez, who also faces charges in Orange County and San Francisco for two other 1985 shooting incidents, to remain in jail without bail.
The lanky, long-haired defendant is accused of having whipped Californians into a frenzy of fear by creeping through unlocked windows and sliding-glass doors of seemingly random residences--many of them in serene San Gabriel Valley communities--in the middle of the night, murdering, raping or robbing the startled victims inside.
List of Charges
In all, Ramirez will be tried for 14 murders, 5 attempted murders, 15 burglaries, 5 robberies, 4 rapes, 3 acts of oral copulation and 4 acts of sodomy involving attacks on 16 Los Angeles County households between June, 1984, and his arrest in East Los Angeles on Aug. 31, 1985.
Nelson also ruled that because of special circumstances--multiple murder counts and murders committed during robberies--Ramirez could face the death penalty if convicted.
The judge dismissed 18 additional felony counts at the request of the prosecution, which declined to present witnesses to buttress those charges. Many of those counts involved alleged sexual molestations of three young boys and girls whose parents requested that they not testify at the public court sessions.
Counts of robbery and burglary at the residence of an 85-year-old Monrovia woman were dropped because the victim died before the start of the hearing.
“The preliminary hearing has gone quite smoothly,” Deputy Dist. Atty. P. Philip Halpin said after the judge’s decision. “I’m satisfied. I felt confident that we had the evidence to bind him over (for trial).”
While the prosecutor made no opening or closing statements to explain Ramirez’s alleged motives, he said late Tuesday that the crimes were “predicated on a series of burglaries . . . which led to a series of other crimes.”
Halpin gave no indication that the crimes were motivated by devil worship, a recurrent theme in the Ramirez case.
The prosecutor said that he will request that Ramirez’s trial begin this summer. He predicted it could last six months, including jury selection.
However, defense counsels Arturo Hernandez and Daniel Hernandez countered that the proceeding may not begin until early 1987 because they plan to file a slew of pretrial motions, including a request for a change of venue.
“Obviously, anybody in this county who lived through the year of the Night Stalker incidents is going to have a very strong feeling about it,” Daniel Hernandez said. “The change of venue issue is going to be a primary issue in this case.”
If possible, the lawyer said, he will seek to have the trial held in the Oakland area, although he conceded that, due to prosecution opposition, he will face an uphill battle in persuading a judge to move the case from Los Angeles County.
Both defense counsels practice law in San Jose.
Daniel Hernandez said that there is a “very strong possibility” that Ramirez will testify during the trial and added that there is also a possibility that Ramirez will choose to plead insanity.
Ramirez’s lawyers presented no affirmative defense during the preliminary hearing and made no closing statement. Arturo Hernandez said the lawyers will wait until the trial to present their defense because they did not receive needed evidence from the prosecution in time to prepare their case and because “there’s no reason to use up all our ammunition at this time.”
Believes Politics Played Part
Arturo Hernandez said his client was not surprised by the hearing’s outcome because he “felt there was a lot of politics involved in the decision of the judge” due to public outcry over the Night Stalker attacks.
But the attorney added that Ramirez felt the dismissal of the 18 charges suggested that “we won . . . a significant breakthrough.” The child molestation counts in particular were “bogus,” the defense counsel said.
Over the course of nine weeks, Halpin presented 531 exhibits and a steady stream of eyewitnesses, police investigators, physicians and scientific experts to link Ramirez to the series of shootings, slashings, robberies and sexual attacks.
In all, six surviving victims identified Ramirez in court as their assailant. The victims, all women, spoke emotionally of being surprised in their bedrooms by a tall, thin attacker with poor teeth who brandished a gun. Four of the women were sexually assaulted, while the other two survived being shot in the head.
Other key evidence included 84 pieces of jewelry and other stolen goods recovered from acquaintances and relatives of Ramirez in Los Angeles, the Bay Area and El Paso. Each of the items--including a television taken from a Diamond Bar murder victim and rings taken from a murdered Glendale couple--were identified in court by surviving victims or relatives of deceased victims.
During the last week, Halpin called a handful of scientific experts to finish weaving an elaborate web of physical, eyewitness and circumstantial evidence, all aimed at tying Ramirez to each of the crime scenes.
For example, a ballistics expert testified Monday that a Monterey Park homicide victim, William Doi, 66, was shot with a bullet from a gun previously linked to Ramirez in court.
And on Tuesday an expert testified that shoe prints found at the scene of several crimes came from the same type of Avia aerobic shoes. Police, however, never recovered such shoes from Ramirez.
The lengthy hearing generally proceeded smoothly, except for occasional bickering between Halpin and the defense attorneys and a courtroom scuffle last week in which Ramirez was pummeled by bailiffs who apparently became upset when he turned his head in the direction of a witness who was being escorted past him.
At other times during the hearing, Ramirez stared eerily at witnesses and grinned broadly during the presentation of such graphic details as the discovery of the mutilated body of Whittier resident Maxine Zazzara, who was found in her bedroom last March with her eyeballs gouged out.
It has been alleged that Ramirez is a devil worshiper, and at a court session before the preliminary hearing, he startled observers by shouting “Hail Satan!” and flashing a pentagram inked on the palm of his hand.
During the hearing, several references to Satan were heard, including evidence that pentagrams, scrawled in lipstick, were found on the thigh of murder victim Mabel Bell, 83, and on the bedroom wall of her Monrovia home.
Authorities also found a pentagram scrawled on the dashboard of Ramirez’s car, which they recovered shortly after his arrest.
Start your day right
Sign up for Essential California for news, features and recommendations from the L.A. Times and beyond in your inbox six days a week.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.