Hall Pass
- Share via
Baseball is a sucker for maudlin moments and this one stoked enough nostalgic fires to light the way from Seattle to Cooperstown, N.Y.
Players from both All-Star dugouts streamed onto Safeco Field to salute Tony Gwynn and Cal Ripken Jr., two soon-to-be-retired sure-fire hall of famers and undisputed class acts.
For the record:
12:00 a.m. Aug. 8, 2001 FOR THE RECORD
Los Angeles Times Wednesday August 8, 2001 Home Edition Part A Part A Page 2 A2 Desk 1 inches; 19 words Type of Material: Correction
Baseball--Brooklyn Dodger catcher Roy Campanella had 1,161 hits in his career. The information was incorrect in a graphic Sunday.
In homes everywhere, dad gushed at the sight of two aging superstars who looked like his friends--one fat, the other bald--while junior nearly burst out of his Ichiro T-shirt at the sight of his heroes.
Standing near Ripken was Jason Giambi, a smoldering sight with tattooed arms and goatee. Next to Gwynn was Todd Helton, looking as cool as a Rocky Mountain refreshment.
For better or worse, baseball revels in its past. Grown men maintain an infantile infatuation over the Babe, get weepy over Wee Willie Keeler and loopy over Dizzy Dean.
But maybe it’s time to shake out the Cobb-webs and survey the diamond--the glory days are upon us. Certainly, a greater number of Hall of Fame careers are being built than at any time since 1967, the say-hey heyday of Cooperstown-bound ballplayers.
In ’67 it was Aaron, Aparicio, Banks, Bench, Brock, Bunning, Carew, Carlton, Cepeda . . .
Today it’s Alomar, Bagwell, Biggio, Bonds, Brown, Canseco, Clemens, Cone, Franco, Galarraga . . .
Everyone with a stake in the game--owners, the players’ union, networks and the guy who hawks memorabilia--can only pray that in 20 years youngsters of today will get a lump in their throat when an All-Star game is stopped to honor Albert Pujols and Tim Hudson.
Or Troy Glaus and Vladimir Guerrero.
Or Shawn Green and Mike Sweeney.
Or whomever. Set aside those players with only a few years’ experience. There are plenty more names with Hall of Fame game. According to formulas devised by baseball historian Bill James, 40 current players already have the numbers to merit strong Cooperstown consideration.
Someday their mere mention will prompt the same sweet smiles and faraway looks that the stars of 1967 elicit now. An all-time high 35 players active that year were eventually voted into the Hall of Fame by the Baseball Writers Assn. of America and two more have been inducted by the Committee on Baseball Veterans.
In ’67 it was Clemente, Drysdale, Ford, Gibson, Hunter, Jackson, Jenkins, Kaline, Killebrew . . .
Today it’s Garciaparra, Glavine, Gonzalez, Griffey, Gwynn, Helton, Henderson, Jeter, Johnson, Chipper Jones . . .
Gwynn grew up admiring the greats of the ‘60s. He admires today’s players too, many of whom were children when he was a rookie in 1982.
“When I’m out there, I have in my own mind who is a hall of famer,” Gwynn said. “It’s easier for me to see it in other guys, whether or not they are worthy. There were a lot of guys on that field [at the All-Star game] who eventually will be there.”
Predicting who will get in can be tricky. The writers typically elect one to four players a year. The Veterans’ Committee currently chooses only one player annually, but its rules are changed more often than the batteries in a hearing aid.
The Veterans’ Committee of the 2030s could easily open the floodgates to current stars overlooked by the writers. After all, old-timers named Buck, King, Eppa, Elmer, Red, Chick, Amos and Addie were inducted with numbers that pale in comparison to those of today’s stars.
An era viewed with particular fondness by earlier Veterans’ Committees was the late 1920s. Fifty-two players active in 1928 have been inducted, but only 28 by the writers, seven fewer than the 1967 group.
In ’67 it was Mantle, Marichal, Mathews, Mays, McCovey, Morgan, Niekro, Palmer, Perez, Perry . . .
Today it’s Larkin, Lofton, Maddux, Pedro Martinez, Edgar Martinez, McGriff, McGwire, Palmeiro, Piazza, Raines . . .
But the biggest difference between 1928, 1967 and today is not perception, it’s pitching. Statistical standards must be adjusted to reflect the going, going, gone ‘90s.
“It’s interesting that 1967 was an era dominated by pitchers, yet all those guys got in the Hall of Fame,” James said. “It’s the opposite today.”
For example, 600 home runs has become what 500 was 40 years ago.
When Ted Williams hit his 500th home run in 1960, only three players had previously done it--Babe Ruth, Jimmie Foxx and Mel Ott. The list has grown to 17. It’s a near certainty that Mark McGwire and Barry Bonds will reach 600, and they will be Nos. 4 and 5 to do so behind Hank Aaron, Ruth and Willie Mays.
But if hitting standards ratchet up, pitching standards must drop. Voters will have to reconcile their aversion to closers. Bottom line: the number of qualified active candidates will probably grow.
Like Casey Kasem, James’ formulas identify the Top 40. Yet several players not on the list--Gary Sheffield, Harold Baines, Paul O’Neill and Omar Vizquel among them--boast numbers comparable to many hall of famers.
Then there are guys who haven’t played long enough to compile the necessary stats, but who will. And how many rookies have untapped greatness? The rookie class of 1967 included Johnny Bench, Rod Carew, Reggie Jackson and Tom Seaver. That year, Bench batted .163 and Jackson .178.
In ’67 it was Brooks Robinson, Frank Robinson, Ryan, Seaver, Stargell, Sutton, Wilhelm, Williams, Yastrzemski.
Today it’s Ramirez, A-Rod, I-Rod, Ripken, Smoltz, Sosa, Thomas, Vaughn, Walker, Williams.
Assembling a career worthy of Cooperstown can be a daunting thought for a young player. Sweeney is well down the list of hard-hitting active first basemen, but his 2000 season is worth noting: .333 average, 29 homers, 144 runs batted in.
Repeat it a dozen times and it’s hello Hall of Fame.
“The consistency and longevity, that’s the tough part,” Sweeney said. “I’ve had 2 1/2 solid years. To look at Cal Ripken and Tony Gwynn and their 20-plus solid years, that’s amazing.”
Long careers fold one era over the next, Nap Lajoie to Ruth, Ruth to Hank Greenberg, Greenberg to Duke Snider, Snider to Willie Stargell, Stargell to Gwynn.
Hanging in the home of Sweeney’s parents is a 1986 photo of their son at 12 standing with Gwynn. Fifteen years later, Gwynn and Ripken prepare to count down the five years before their Hall of Fame inductions. Sweeney and dozens of others earnestly pursue the dream. A September call-up will take his first step toward Cooperstown when he walks into a big league clubhouse.
Baseball connects generations. Dad is sentimental about yesterday and the kids are excited about tomorrow. But take a look around, the best players are active today.
(BEGIN TEXT OF INFOBOX / INFOGRAPHIC)
Busting Out--Selection of players who are building the stats to qualify for baseball’s most prestigious accolade, the Hall of Fame.
Bagwell
Martinez
Williams
Larkin
Piazza
Biggio
Alomar
Palmeiro
Times researcher Houston Mitchell compares some contemporary players with Hall of Famers who hae played in a similar number of games:
Outfielders
Players: Kenny Lofton
G: 1,314
AB: 5,238
R: 1,003
H: 1,582
2B: 245
3B: 67
HR: 85
RBI: 521
AVG: .302
OB%: .378
SLG%: .423
*
Players: Ross Youngs
G: 1,211
AB: 4,627
R: 812
H: 1,491
2B: 236
3B: 93
HR: 42
RBI: 592
AVG: .322
OB%: .399
SLG%: .441
*
Players: Andres Galarraga
G: 1,993
AB: 7,393
R: 1,113
H: 2,136
2B: 409
3B: 32
HR: 371
RBI: 1,318
AVG: .289
OB%: .347
SLG%: .503
*
Players: Johnny Mize
G: 1,884
AB: 6,443
R: 1,118
H: 2,011
2B: 367
3B: 83
HR: 359
RBI: 1,337
AVG: .312
OB%: .397
SLG%: .562
*
Players: Tim Raines
G: 2,375
AB: 8,728
R: 1,544
H: 2,570
2B: 421
3B: 112
HR: 168
RBI: 964
AVG: .294
OB%: .386
SLG%: .426
*
Players: Max Carey
G: 2,476
AB: 9,363
R: 1,545
H: 2,665
2B: 419
3B: 159
HR: 70
RBI: 800
AVG: .285
OB%: .361
SLG%: .386
*
Players: Bernie Williams
G: 1,237
AB: 4,806
R: 862
H: 1,463
2B: 278
3B: 50
HR: 181
RBI: 802
AVG: .304
OB%: .392
SLG%: .496
*
Players: Chick Hafey
G: 1,283
AB: 4,625
R: 777
H: 1,466
2B: 341
3B: 67
HR: 164
RBI: 833
AVG: .317
OB%: .372
SLG%: .526
*
Players: Sammy Sosa
G: 1,668
AB: 6,258
R: 1,030
H: 1,715
2B: 271
3B: 38
HR: 421
RBI: 1,178
AVG: .274
OB%: .339
SLG%: .531
*
Players: Albert Belle
G: 1,539
AB: 5,853
R: 974
H: 1,726
2B: 389
3B: 21
HR: 381
RBI: 1,239
AVG: .295
OB%: .374
SLG%: .564
*
Players: Juan Gonzalez
G: 1,457
AB: 5,652
R: 933
H: 1,678
2B: 337
3B: 22
HR: 389
RBI: 1,237
AVG: .297
OB%: .346
SLG%: .571
*
Players: Ralph Kiner
G: 1,472
AB: 5,205
R: 971
H: 1,451
2B: 216
3B: 39
HR: 369
RBI: 1,015
AVG: .279
OB%: .398
SLG%: .548
Infielders
Players: Frank Thomas
G: 1,550
AB: 5,542
R: 1,091
H: 1,770
2B: 364
3B: 10
HR: 348
RBI: 1,193
AVG: .319
OB%: .438
SLG%: .577
*
Players: Jeff Bagwell
G: 1,582
AB: 5,752
R: 1,155
H: 1,747
2B: 376
3B: 24
HR: 338
RBI: 1,183
AVG: .304
OB%: .415
SLG%: .554
*
Players: Hank Greenberg
G: 1,394
AB: 5,193
R: 1,051
H: 1,628
2B: 379
3B: 71
HR: 331
RBI: 1,276
AVG: .313
OB%: .412
SLG%: .605
*
Players: Roberto Alomar
G: 1,980
AB: 7,606
R: 1,306
H: 2,333
2B: 435
3B: 68
HR: 183
RBI: 986
AVG: .307
OB%: .378
SLG%: .454
*
Players: Bobby Doerr
G: 1,865
AB: 7,093
R: 1,094
H: 2,042
2B: 381
3B: 89
HR: 223
RBI: 1,247
AVG: .288
OB%: .362
SLG%: .461
*
Players: Mike Piazza
G: 1,210
AB: 4,466
R: 753
H: 1,453
2B: 214
3B: 34
HR: 304
RBI: 944
AVG: .325
OB%: .391
SLG%: .579
*
Players: Roy Campanella
G: 1,215
AB: 4,205
R: 627
H: 1,611
2B: 178
3B: 18
HR: 242
RBI: 856
AVG: .276
OB%: .362
SLG%: .500
*
Players: Edgar Martinez
G: 1,624
AB: 5,720
R: 1,031
H: 1,824
2B: 430
3B: 14
HR: 249
RBI: 995
AVG: .319
OB%: .426
SLG%: .530
*
Players: Earl Averill
G: 1,668
AB: 6,353
R: 1,224
H: 2,019
2B: 401
3B: 128
HR: 238
RBI: 1,164
AVG: .318
OB%: .395
SLG%: .534
*
Players: Rafael Palmeiro
G: 2,202
AB: 8,234
R: 1,318
H: 2,425
2B: 478
3B: 36
HR: 428
RBI: 1,423
AVG: .295
OB%: .372
SLG%: .517
*
Players: Fred McGriff
G: 2,154
AB: 7,702
R: 1,214
H: 2,216
2B: 390
3B: 20
HR: 436
RBI: 1,361
AVG: .288
OB%: .382
SLG%: .513
*
Players: Orlando Cepeda
G: 2,124
AB: 7,927
R: 1,131
H: 2,351
2B: 417
3B: 27
HR: 379
RBI: 1,365
AVG: .297
OB%: .353
SLG%: .499
*
Players: Barry Larkin
G: 1,854
AB: 6,843
R: 1,161
H: 2,048
2B: 373
3B: 70
HR: 181
RBI: 851
AVG: .299
OB%: .377
SLG%: .454
*
Players: Tony Lazzeri
G: 1,740
AB: 6,297
R: 986
H: 1,840
2B: 334
3B: 115
HR: 178
RBI: 1,191
AVG: .292
OB%: .380
SLG%: .467
*
Players: Ivan Rodriguez
G: 1,346
AB: 5,151
R: 770
H: 1,564
2B: 307
3B: 26
HR: 192
RBI: 754
AVG: .304
OB%: .340
SLG%: .485
*
Players: Ernie Lombardi
G: 1,853
AB: 5,855
R: 601
H: 1,792
2B: 277
3B: 27
HR: 190
RBI: 990
AVG: .306
OB%: .358
SLG%: .460
*
Players: Larry Walker
G: 1,480
AB: 5,243
R: 1,027
H: 1,641
2B: 359
3B: 44
HR: 299
RBI: 994
AVG: .313
OB%: .393
SLG%: .569
*
Players: Hack Wilson
G: 1,348
AB: 4,760
R: 884
H: 1,461
2B: 266
3B: 67
HR: 244
RBI: 1,063
AVG: .307
OB%: .395
SLG%: .545
*
Players: Craig Biggio
G: 1,902
AB: 7,174
R: 1,269
H: 2,095
2B: 427
3B: 44
HR: 176
RBI: 790
AVG: .292
OB%: .382
SLG%: .437
*
Players: Lou Boudreau
G: 1,646
AB: 6,029
R: 861
H: 1,779
2B: 385
3B: 66
HR: 68
RBI: 789
AVG: .295
OB%: .380
SLG%: .415
Pitchers
*--*
Pitcher G IP H BB SO W-L ERA Tom Glavine 434 2,900 2,751 965 1,811 208-125 3.39 Bob Lemon 460 2,850 2,559 1,251 1,277 207-128 3.23 David Cone 420 2,745 2,336 1,067 2,540 184-116 3.40 Lefty Gomez 368 2,503 2,290 1,095 1,468 189-102 3.34
*--*
*
BASEBALL HALL OF FAME
TODAY, 10:30 A.M., ESPN CLASSIC , COOPERSTOWN, N.Y.
More to Read
Go beyond the scoreboard
Get the latest on L.A.'s teams in the daily Sports Report newsletter.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.