Oakland City Council backtracks, voting to add police as it grapples with rise in homicides

Carl Chan, president of the Oakland Chinatown Chamber of Commerce
Carl Chan, president of the Oakland Chinatown Chamber of Commerce, speaks at a news conference on public safety Tuesday.
(Anda Chu / Bay Area News Group)

The Oakland City Council, a longtime leader in the Black Lives Matter movement to cut police funding, reversed course Tuesday and voted to hire more officers as it grapples with a rise in homicides and gun violence.

The proposal by Mayor Libby Schaaf to add two police academies and unfreeze positions within the department to add 60 new officers passed with six members voting yes, one voting no and one abstention.

Council members ended up not voting on a separate proposal to offer one-off bonuses of at least $50,000 to recruit experienced officers from other cities and at least $20,000 to Oakland residents who become police cadets. They will consider hiring incentives for experienced officers later.


Schaaf applauded the vote in a statement, saying that residents “spoke up for a comprehensive approach to public safety — one that includes prevention, intervention and addressing crime’s root causes, as well as an adequately staffed police department.”

Oakland is among several politically liberal cities reversing course on police funding amid a spike in violence, to the dismay of police critics who have said officers are ineffective at preventing crime and end up traumatizing residents, especially Black people. They have said that there is no staffing shortage within the police department, and that officers should focus on the most serious crimes.

“What’s terrifying about this is, as Oakland goes, so goes the country,” said Cat Brooks, co-founder of Oakland’s Anti-Police Terror Project, urging the council to vote down increased police staffing. “If we allow it to be demolished here, we are giving fuel for faux progressives and right-wing folks to destroy the movement across the country.”

An investigation showed the group shared offensive content online while using their work cellphones.

Sept. 20, 2021

Oakland has had 129 homicides this year, up from 109 last year and 78 in 2019. The deaths include a toddler who was napping in a moving vehicle when he was hit by a stray bullet on an Oakland freeway and a retired police officer who was shot while working as a security guard for a television news crew. Both killings occurred in broad daylight.

The city’s police force of sworn officers now stands at 676, dipping below a 2014 voter-approved measure that required the police department to have at least 678 sworn officers. The city of more than 400,000 people started this year with 723 sworn officers.

Barry Donelan, president of the Oakland Police Officers’ Assn., said officers are “leaving in droves” for other cities and urged council members to thank police rather than malign them.


Oakland has joined other cities in diverting police from some 911 calls to reduce friction between law enforcement and minority groups. A pilot program to use trained civilians to address complaints such as public intoxication and panhandling is scheduled to be launched early next year.

Oakland police say the march began peacefully, but the crowd began throwing objects at officers.

April 17, 2021

With Tuesday’s vote, Oakland joins other cities that have seen robust Black Lives Matter activism but that have partially restored public safety finances in response to rising homicides, an officer exodus and political pressure.

Last month, the city council in Portland, Ore., did an about-face on police funding after cutting the public safety budget in the midst of protests over the 2020 police murder of George Floyd. The council unanimously passed a budget that increased the current $230 million police budget by $5.2 million.