Archive for Sunday, August 10, 2008
Adding the insult of a distressed health system to a quake injury
Remember the July 29 earthquake that rocked Southern California but produced no injuries?
It turns out there were at least two broken bones after all. So says a UC Irvine Medical Center doctor who treated Jesus Rodriguez, an unlucky chap who came tumbling off the roof of a house he was working on when the temblor struck.
And that was just the beginning of Rodriguez’s troubles.
“If the news media were correct and the quake … was a drill, I’d say health services gets an F,” Dr. Michael Menchine said. “You just can’t make this stuff up.”
Rodriguez, 25, lost a full-time job recently when his uncle’s construction business went under. So he began joining other day laborers each morning at the Home Depot on Beach Boulevard in Stanton, queuing up and hoping for work.
Three or four times a week, he lucked out. Rodriguez is a U.S. citizen and Orange County native who speaks English, all of which helps at times when contractors come trolling for crews. He’s also got a lot of experience, in everything from carpeting to window installation to masonry.
It irks him, he said, that he has to compete for those jobs against illegal immigrants. When I asked how many of the guys were illegal, he chuckled.
“Like, 90%,” he said.
It’s not just the competition that bugs him. He believes wages are driven down by illegal immigrants, who are easily exploited by employers.
On the morning of the earthquake, a man pulled up in a white pickup and hired Rodriguez and two other guys. Rodriguez didn’t know the other two. Little was said on the way to the job except that it involved roofing, and it would pay $10 an hour.
Two hours into the shingle job, Rodriguez was on the sloped roof of a one-story house when he suddenly felt like he was on a boat in rough seas. He could feel himself teetering on the edge in the quake, and he managed a quick look down.
“I saw some debris down there, so I pushed off to get over it,” he said of his fall.
He landed on both feet, but was in such pain he couldn’t stand.
The man who had driven him to the job helped him back into the truck and began driving.
To a hospital, you ask?
Guess again.
“He said he didn’t want to deal with that,” said Rodriguez.
The driver took him back to Home Depot, helped him out of the truck and left him on a grassy patch near a KFC.
Then he drove away.
Rodriguez tried reaching Ukia, the mother of his kids and the woman he calls his common-law wife, but the phone lines were dead after the earthquake. When he finally got through, she left her job as a telemarketer and raced over. She’s big and strong and was able to lift Rodriguez into her van and drive him to West Anaheim Medical Center, where the news was not good.
X-rays showed two broken heels. Rodriguez was splinted, given a referral to an orthopedic specialist and sent home. But Ukia had one stop to make first.
“We went back to Home Depot to see if he could recognize any of the guys he worked with, or if anyone knew the contractor,” she said. “It’s not right that they just dumped him there like that.”
But they struck out and went home.
When Ukia later called to make the orthopedic appointment, she was told that Rodriguez would need $260 in cash to get in the door, and $300 per cast.
They didn’t have the money.
Ukia worked the phones trying to get him qualified for Orange County’s Medical Services Initiative, which covers indigent adults. But the next morning, Rodriguez was hurting so badly she drove him to UCI Medical Center.
“There’s absolutely no reason for him to be back in ER that day. He just came back because he was unable to do the follow-up,” said Menchine, who complained of the chronic stress on emergency rooms because so many patients have nowhere else to go. “It’s not his fault. People clearly need help, but they don’t need to see us.”
Menchine and his cohorts did another round of X-rays, redid the splints, got an orthopedic consult and referred Rodriguez for a follow-up appointment that was scheduled for last Tuesday. But Ukia, who had finally lined up temporary insurance after a maddening run-around, was told there was no record of the appointment.
On Friday – 10 days after his injury – Rodriguez finally saw a specialist and found out that his best option is surgery. The recovery could take three months or more.
The fact that he’ll finally get treated doesn’t mean the system works, Menchine said. The payments for his kind of insurance are rock-bottom, so many physicians don’t accept it. And too many patients with limited insurance, or none at all, opt for ERs or wait too long for needed care.
The answer?
Menchine said he thought that among the original crop of presidential candidates, Sen. Hillary Clinton’s universal health insurance plan was the best. Not that it would ever have materialized without a miracle, given all the special interests that profit from the maddening status quo.
I spent two days trying to find the house Rodriguez fell from, because it’s possible that a homeowner’s insurance policy might help cover his injuries. But he only remembered the general vicinity and I had no luck.
At Home Depot, I spoke to more than a dozen day laborers, trying to track the contractor who dumped Rodriguez without taking him to the hospital – or paying him for his two hours of work before the quake.
Either they didn’t know or they were afraid to speak. One told me he cut his hand on a job and the contractor didn’t pay a nickel of the $700 bill. Others say they sometimes get shorted on their pay.
If anyone out there has any information on the contractor who hired Rodriguez, please contact me. Lawyers have told me there might be a way to hold him liable for dumping Rodriguez like a wounded dog.
While I spoke to day laborers, a guy pulled up in a white truck and hired two men.
Was he the guy?
I may never know.
When I told him what I was looking for, he hit the gas even as he tossed me this line:
“It’s not my deal, man.”
- BMW 335d sedan: Elegant electronics and a gestalt-altering diesel
- Palin ethics lapse cited
- Golden Gate Bridge to get suicide net to catch would-be jumpers
- Armenian clergy worldwide embark on a quest to collect holy oil
- The 'unitary executive' question
- Leland Wong gets 5 years in 'pay to play' corruption scandal
- California takes steps to probe nurses' criminal backgrounds
- House of Blues' image contrasting upgrades on Sunset Strip
- Endorsements so far
- Japanese businessman Kazuyoshi Miura is found dead in jail cell
- Ethics probe hits hardest at Todd, not Sarah Palin
- Bank rescue plan to test capitalism
- A USC victory, yes, but it's no keeper
- Obama rides a wave of bad economic news
- Oregon defeats UCLA, 31-24
- Who's best suited for the White House?
- McCain campaign sees Iowa as still in play
- Josh Brolin takes a run at the president in 'W.'
- Sarah Palin's husband, Todd, was a fixture at governor's office
- John McCain and Sarah Palin try new tactics
