No one even pretends anymore that the college version of a great game, conceived by James Naismith and propagated by John Wooden, is in good shape.
This season's national per-team scoring average, according to analytics guru Ken Pomeroy, was 66.85 points per game entering the NCAA tournament, which began Tuesday. That projects to eclipse the record low of 66.91 points in 2012-13.
College basketball coaches are strangling free-flow offense with their incessant use of timeouts and go-slow tactics of clock-shot management.
The exodus of one-and-done players to the
"You don't need any talent to play defense," said Fox analyst Kevin O'Neill, a former
Basketball has become the opposite of football, where defenses are chasing innovative, fast-paced college offenses like those run at
College hoops lacks a "counterpunch" to the molasses movement, said John Akers, editor of Basketball Times, a website devoted to the game.
The stingiest teams exhaust the 35-second shot clock while, as Pomeroy puts it, "hunting and pecking" for offense.
Virginia, the Atlantic Coast Conference regular-season champion the last two seasons, is a prototype for today's style. The Cavaliers rank 221st in scoring offense (65.3 points per game) but hold opponents to a national low of 50.7 points.
During a recent game at
The complaints are not coming from people who hate the game; they're coming from those who love it.
"I think the game is in crisis," said Doug Gottlieb, a former college player who is a
College basketball has two distinct seasons: what might be called the "Mundane Months" and the one everyone loves, "March Madness."
The NCAA tournament has become a three-week spectacular, like a World Cup or an Olympics. It is exciting, gambler-friendly and compelling even to casual fans. The lack of aesthetics gets overlooked because of the single-elimination drama and sizzling Cinderella story lines — USC Coach
Perhaps nothing has been more damaging than awarding automatic
College basketball is a cautionary tale for why college football doesn't want to risk its riveting regular season for an extended playoff.
The best players and coaches pose different sorts of problems. The elite players don't stay in college long, and the top coaches justify their mega salaries by suffocating the game with their expertise.
Complex data provided by services such as Synergy Sports and by Pomeroy at KenPom.com also may be stagnating the action. "No doubt, increased information helps defense more than offense," Pomeroy said.
National attendance figures sagged 2.2% in 2013-14 and it looks like the trend continued this season as cable and conference networks saturated the airwaves with games.
Fans once eagerly awaited intersectional rivalries like
On a recent Saturday in Los Angeles, 51 college games were available on television.
ESPN has yet to seize broadcast rights for the NCAA tournament. It overcompensates by seemingly airing every game from November to the Sunday when the field of 68 teams is announced.
The season itself is boxed in: on the front end by college football, at the back by CBS, which spent billions of dollars for the rights to broadcast the NCAA games and then, immediately after, the Masters golf tournament.
"Don't compete with football," Gottlieb said. "That's stupid. That's death."
So extend the season?
That's not a popular idea, either.
"March, that's our month," Big West Commissioner Dennis Farrell said. "We own March. Why would we give that up?"
Today's problems can be traced in part to a tournament going overboard as it adjusted from being so exclusive that it left out teams that could have challenged for a national title.
USC didn't make the tournament in 1971 despite going 24-2 because only league champions made the field and the Trojans lost twice to UCLA, which would win the national title. But the team that really tipped the course of postseason history was the 1974
Maryland was led by three superstars — Len Elmore, Tom McMillen and
The NCAA reacted by expanding to 32 teams the next year, then to 40 in 1979 and 48 in 1980, to 64 in 1985 and to 68 in 2011.
He was warned by his mentor, Big East co-founder Dave Gavitt.
"He was not happy when the tournament went from 48 to 64," Tranghese said of Gavitt. "He thought we'd gone too far."