Football Safety Risky Business : Death of Reseda High Player Raises Questions Concerning Prevention, Treatment of Injuries

With their helmets, pads and designer accessories, high school football players are outfitted like modern gladiators. Yet they remain alarmingly vulnerable.

When a Reseda High player died in his sleep last Friday the morning after a taxing season opener, that much was underscored.

Eric Hoggatt, a running back, defensive back and kick returner, complained of dizziness and numbness in his legs and fingers during the game. Hoggatt was benched by a team physician late in a 41-0 loss against Chatsworth, ut members of the player’s family say they were not told of his symptoms.

The cause of Hoggatt’s death has not been tied to the football game, and details will not be known until a coroner’s report is released, probably next month. But circumstances of the tragedy have raised questions and concerns about the safety of young athletes, especially those in contact sports.

“It is extremely rare to have an incident like this, but parents have known for decades that football is a dangerous sport,” said Shel Erlich, a spokesman for Los Angeles Unified School District. “Playing football is a decision the parent and student should make together.”

In California, high school football players are required to pass a physical examination before the season. Also, physicians are present at most games, helmets must meet national safety standards and coaches and referees are trained to recognize danger signs.

But preemptive measures don’t always succeed.

Nationally last year, four high school players died from head-related injuries and five died from heatstroke, the most football fatalities since 1988.

At Southern California high schools, there have been two football-related deaths in seven years. Sergio Echevarria, a San Fernando High senior, collapsed after a preseason conditioning practice in 1992 and died two days later from heatstroke. Kiet Le, a Westminster La Quinta High sophomore, collapsed during a junior varsity game in 1989 and died after undergoing brain surgery.

Victoria Osollo, whose son, Ben Kaminsky, plays center for Reseda, said Hoggatt’s death has prompted her to question procedures regarding the treatment and medical follow-up of injured players.

“It brought up a lot of concerns,” Osollo said. “I definitely think [the family] should have been contacted.”

Sideline physicians face the daunting task of making instantaneous decisions during the heat of a game.

“Two things scare the pants off of us,” said Mel Hayashi, for 23 years the team physician for Newbury Park High. “One is head injuries, and the other is heart arrhythmia.”

Numbness and dizziness indicate injury to the head or spinal cord, said Sanbo Sakaguchi, a general surgeon and the Alemany High team physician of 30 years.

“If [a player] comes out and complains of severe dizziness, you know it is a head injury,” Sakaguchi said. “He doesn’t play any more. It’s pretty clear-cut.”

Hayashi, an orthopedic surgeon, said he tests groggy players by quizzing them on their assignments for specific plays. “I have him stand beside me the whole time he is out of the game,” Hayashi said. “I keep asking questions and will keep him out until I am certain he is responding properly.”

If Hoggatt had a preexisting health problem, it didn’t show up during his physical, according to Reseda Athletic Director Norman Weiler.

“Everything was in perfect order,” Weiler said.

The L.A. Unified School District, of which Reseda High is a member, issues a standardized form to each player, who must have it signed by a physician. All of Reseda’s players went to their own physicians because examinations were not available at school, Weiler said.

Among other tests, players are given a cardiac examination, in which their pulse is taken while they are at rest and after doing 25 hops. Players also are checked for abnormalities of the internal organs, nervous system and musculoskeletal system, including the spinal cord.

Medical availability varies from school to school.

At San Clemente High, administrators make physicians available on campus before each season of sport--fall, winter and spring. Athletes can also choose to see their family doctor.

At Paraclete, a small Catholic school in Lancaster, the thoroughness of the physical is left to the discretion of the doctor, Athletic Director Margaret Neill said.

Parents and athletes in all sports at Hart High are required to sign a waiver acknowledging that “serious, catastrophic, or fatal injury may result from athletic participation.”

But Mike Herrington, athletic director and coach of the successful Hart football team, acknowledged that the waiver might not protect the school or its employees from liability.

“You know, you can get sued for anything,” Herrington said. “[The waiver] might not hold up in courts at all, but who knows? We want to make parents aware of the situation.”

Some LAUSD schools distribute letters warning families of the risks of interscholastic athletics, but parents are not required to sign and return them.

“The best thing for parents to tell their kids is that if they are in an athletic situation, practice or game, there is the chance of injury,” said Barbara Fiege, City Section athletic director.

“If a player is injured, he needs to inform personnel on the sidelines,” she said. “Sometimes kids don’t want to tell the coach because they don’t want to come out of the game.”

Jeanne Harrison, whose son, Jeremiah, plays football for Reseda, said parents should be aware they are taking a risk when they allow their children to play a sport, particularly a contact sport.

“As a mother, you’re concerned whenever one of your kids is in a sport, but we always let our kids make their own decisions,” Harrison said. “Whenever there’s a risk, you take all the precautions you possibly can. The rest, you leave up to God.”

Although the California Interscholastic Federation does not mandate that a physician be present at athletic events, many teams would no sooner start a game without a physician than without an official.

North Hollywood High games have been delayed because a doctor was late in arriving, Coach Gary Gray said.

Coaches routinely defer to the team physician when the safety of a player is in question.

“If our doctor says a player cannot play, we don’t argue the point,” Gray said. “Sometimes we don’t agree. If a player is complaining that his head hurts, that’s the doctor’s call.”

Schools in affluent areas tend to provide better medical care. At Westlake, an orthopedic surgeon, a chiropractor and an athletic trainer attend all of the football team’s games--home and away.

Equipment is supposed to be inspected as thoroughly as the players.

Although coaches routinely are asked by game officials during warmups whether players are properly outfitted, the officials do not inspect each player’s equipment.

Helmets must pass guidelines set by the National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment, and a NOCSAE sticker must be affixed to the back of every helmet. The committee was established in 1969, a year after 32 fatalities occurred directly because of participation in football.

Still, helmets remain the single piece of equipment causing the most problems, said Hayashi, the Newbury Park team physician. The padding of the most common football helmets is made of air pockets, which must be inflated to achieve a snug fit.

“[Most] injuries occur because the player did not fill his helmet with air,” Hayashi said.

Rarely s are trained medical personnel on hand to check helmets before practices. Last year, 61% of injuries occurred during practice, according to a National Athletic Trainers Assn. study.

Coaches are most often responsible for issuing equipment and making sure players are properly fitted.

“We check constantly to see if kids have their helmets pumped up correctly,” Hart’s Herrington said.

Calabasas football Coach Larry Edwards said his team does not begin contact drills until players have their helmets fitted by certified representatives of the manufacturer.

At Reseda, Coach Joel Schaeffer said helmets are inspected every year by the coaches.

“You’re constantly checking the helmets [throughout the week] and the kids are told to check them constantly,” Schaeffer said. “Football equipment is not an issue here.”

Game officials are trained to recognize symptoms of concussions and other injuries.

“It’s getting that more and more we err on the side of safety,” said Brad Glenn, a San Fernando Valley referee. “Looking for signs of injury or of a player who appears disoriented is a point of emphasis with officials.”

Physicians who work the sidelines are unpaid volunteers for a more compelling reason: Zero compensation equals full protection.

A state law enacted in 1978 after the death of an Agoura High player protects physicians from liability for civil damages provided they receive no compensation for time spent at games.

The legislation was prompted by the efforts of Howard Cole, whose son, Greg, died as the result of injuries suffered while making a tackle for Agoura in 1977. An athletic trainer was at the game, but no doctor.

Before the legislation, many doctors were unwilling to serve as team physicians because they worried about leaving themselves open to lawsuits.

The law protects physicians who, “in good faith and without compensation,” render voluntary emergency medical assistance to a participant in a school athletic event. Gross negligence is not covered.

Eliminating injuries--even serious ones--is all but impossible. Physicians are rarely present at practices or at freshman and junior varsity games.

For the physician who donates his Friday nights each fall, the best game is one he can simply enjoy from the sidelines without having to treat a player.

“Something like [Hoggatt’s death] doesn’t happen often, thankfully,” Hayashi said. “Everyone feels so sorry. It’s a disaster for everybody.”

*

Times staff writers Chris Foster, Paige A. Leech, David Wharton and Tris Wykes contributed to this story.